AeroPress vs French Press: The ULTIMATE Showdown

Each year 2.5 million French Presses are sold in the United States alone. That’s one French Press sold for every 100 US adults every single year.

Considering many French Press users own theirs for 10-plus years, clearly we’re talking about a large portion of the American public.

The AeroPress is no slouch either. Almost accidentally invented, the small business that launched the revolutionary brewer has sold millions since 2005.

(And we aren’t talking about a whole class of brewers here, we’re talking about a single model from a single company.)

AeroPress vs French Press — which is right for you?

We break it down in The Coffee Maven’s AeroPress vs French Press Ultimate Showdown.

AeroPress vs French Press

Ask almost anyone what their favorite brewing method is and usually you’ll get one of these two answers:

AeroPress or French Press.

Both are cherished by their loyal followings and produce undeniably outstanding coffee, but they proudly sit on opposite ends of the brewing spectrum.

The AeroPress was invented in 2005 and is the new school brewing method. It uses pressure extraction with medium-fine grounds to quickly product a bright, clean brew one cup at a time.

The French Press was first patented in 1929 and is the old school, tried-and-true brewing method.

It uses full immersion with coarse grounds to extract every precious oil and uses a paper-free plunger to separate the solid matter from the coffee to yield a full-bodied, raw, almost unrefined beverage bursting with flavor.

Here’s the AeroPress vs French Press in table form:

Brew MethodExtractionSuggested GrindBrew TimeDominant Coffee DescriptorPrice
AeroPressPressureMedium-fine1 minuteClean$30
French PressSteepingCoarse4 minutesFull-bodied$25
aeropress

What is the AeroPress?

The AeroPress is a new take brewing coffee invented by Aerobie, the company that holds the Guinness world record for longest frisbee toss.

1,333 feet!

(Technically the record is for “longest throw of an object without any velocity-aiding feature” but that doesn’t roll off the tongue as easily.)

You can find some cool videos of their aerodynamic sailing ring on YouTube.

The main point: these guys know their physics.

And it’s those physics that make the AeroPress so amazing.

How Does the AeroPress Work?

Similar in concept to espresso machines, the AeroPress combines coffee grounds, hot water and pressure to aid extraction. The pressure is generated completely by hand as you compress the coffee between the plunger and the ground coffee bed/micro-filter.

You won’t generate the 9 bars required for authentic espresso, but Aerobie says you can generate between 0.35-0.70 bar. That sounds small, but it’s the reason you can speedily make espresso-like concentrates. Besides, the French Press doesn’t have any applied pressure!

How to Use the AeroPress

The AeroPress has 3 parts as shown below:

3 parts of an aeropress

From left to right you have the plunger, chamber and filter cap.

The AeroPress isn’t difficult to use, but mastering it can take some time. Here’s the process.

AeroPress Standard Method

  1. Heat your water: AeroPress recommends 175ºF but find what you like
  2. Grind your beans: Fine or medium-fine grind (or your preference); try 2 level scoops
  3. Insert the filter: Place a paper filter in the filter cap and wet it with the hot water
  4. Attach the filter cap: The filter cap locks into the bottom of the chamber
  5. Add the coffee: Tap a few times to evenly disperse (this is an important step!)
  6. Bring on the mug: Place the chamber on top of your desired mug
  7. Add the water: Pour water into the chamber to the desired level (I always go to level 4)
  8. Stir briefly: Give it a quick stir; don’t linger!
  9. Insert the plunger: Push down for 15-30 seconds but could vary by the recipe
  10. Dilute as needed: Resulting coffee is concentrated; dilute to your tastes

That’s all there is to it! Ten steps seems like a lot, but I basically covered every single unique motion. Depending how long it takes your water to boil or your coffee to be ground, that whole process could take anywhere from 2-5 minutes.

Enjoy this video:

AeroPress Standard Method vs Inverted Method

The steps and video above show what’s called the Standard Method. It’s the original way of using the AeroPress as designed by the inventor.

Some prefer a different method: the Inverted Method.

This method is characterized by, unsurprisingly, inverting the chamber. The steps are similar to those of the Standard Method, except you connect the plunger to the chamber first, then invert it and pour the coffee grounds in. This time the last thing you add is the filter cap and damp paper filter!

Why the second method?

Some AeroPress users like to give the coffee more extraction time, but with the Standard Method this means you get underextracted coffee dripping through the filter into your mug. By inverting the AeroPress and brewing with the plunger on the bottom, you eliminate all dripping. However, inverted brewers are left with the task of re-inverting the hot mixture in order to finish plunging.

These are the steps (much of it will look the same as above).

AeroPress Inverted Method

  1. Heat your water: AeroPress recommends 175ºF but find what you like
  2. Grind your beans: Fine or medium-fine grind (or your preference); try 2 level scoops
  3. Insert the plunger: Place the plunger into the chamber and turn it upside down
  4. Add the coffee: Unlike above, there’s no need to tap to disperse
  5. Add the water: Pour water into the chamber to the desired level (this time I go to level 1)
  6. Stir briefly: You don’t need to stir as quickly this time
  7. Insert the filter: Place a paper filter in the filter cap and wet it with the hot water
  8. Attach the filter cap: The filter cap locks into the bottom of the chamber
  9. Bring on the mug: Place the mug upside down on the inverted device
  10. When ready, flip!: Carefully flip the whole contraption over onto the mug
  11. Plunge: Push down, though you don’t need to do it so slowly this time
  12. Dilute as needed: Resulting coffee is concentrated; dilute to your tastes

And a helpful video of the AeroPress Inverted Method:

The Inverted Method requires a little more in the way of acrobatics and coordination, but it may be right for you.

AeroPress Brewing Tips

1. AeroPress recommends using water at 175ºF versus the standard 200ºF-205ºF (or higher for some). The 30ºF difference in water temp will yield a coffee with hardly any bitterness, which seems to be how the AeroPress inventor likes his coffee. I say try it to see what you prefer.

2. Use a fine or medium-fine grind, which will create the optimal density for the bed of grounds. Be careful not to go too fine or you won’t be able to press the plunger down.

3. For longer extraction time, try the Inverted Method. This method prevents water from dripping through the bed of coffee grounds.

AeroPress Pros

I’m a card carrying member of the AeroPress fan club for the following reasons.

1. Virtually indestructible

I like the convenience of a pod coffee machine as much as the next person, but there’s no denying those machines are expensive and aren’t built to last. The AeroPress is a different story. The construction of AeroPress models has varied over the years, but the current version being sold is made of a BPA-free polypropylene.

Source: AeroPress

You can bang this thing around without any fear of breaking. My AeroPress (shown in a photo above) is the version sold from January through June, 2014, which makes it two models out of date. It was made from a weaker copolyester material, but I’m still using it nearly every day.

Though I haven’t had any issues, the one part I’ve heard some people experience issues with is the rubber seal on the bottom of the plunger. After prolonged use, sometimes those wear down and don’t seal quite as well. They’re extremely easy (and cheap) to replace.

2. Light, compact, portable

The plunger, chamber and filter cap weigh 7 ounces — less than half-a-pound. And because it’s made of durable polyproplylene plastic, you can toss it in your bag and go without worry.

3. Versatile with grind size

The AeroPress was originally designed for brewing with fine or medium-fine grounds via the Standard Method. This grind size is perfect for creating a bed of grounds that’s the proper consistency for the AeroPress’ speedy, pressurized extraction method.

With the Inverted Method the AeroPress can be used with coarser grounds, because the Inverted Method allows for extended steeping.

4. Capable of quicker brewing

When it comes to AeroPress vs French Press brew time, it’s no comparison. Combine the micro-filter (allows you to brew with a finer grind size) with pressure extraction (created by the plunger) and the AeroPress gives you a much more rapid brew time — usually around 1 minute.

5. Incredibly easy to clean

Simple soap and water will do, but the AeroPress is dishwasher safe, too.

AeroPress Cons

No matter how much anyone loves the AeroPress, it ain’t perfect.

1. More complicated

Compared to other coffee makers, the AeroPress is a little harder to use. Think about it:

  • French Press: Mix hot water and grounds, wait, press, pour
  • Pour Over: Place filter in, add grounds, slowly pour water, voila
  • Drip Coffee: Place filter in, add grounds, push a button, wait
  • Pod Coffee: Place in a pod, push a button, wait

The exact steps vary for each of those, but the overall process is a lot simpler (and the AeroPress has more literal parts). I’d also argue the AeroPress takes the most practice to get “right,” by which I mean getting you to what you’d define as your perfect cup of coffee.

2. Less margin for error

By varying the grind size, water temperature and total contact time, you can significantly change the resulting coffee. This is awesome for those who like to experiment, but it can lead to inconsistency from cup to cup if you don’t have your process dialed in.

3. Requires special filters

aeropress filters

A small annoyance, but the AeroPress requires special, circular micro-filters.

The AeroPress kit comes with 350 filters, which should last you 6-12 months, and the filters are cheap to replace off Amazon or directly from Aerobie.

4. Single serve only

Total coffee capacity is a downside of the AeroPress.

The product is designed to yield a coffee concentrate to which you add hot water until you reach your desired strength, but sometimes I still have to go back and make a second cup for myself.

(And when I make coffee for my girlfriend and I on Saturday mornings I have to repeat the whole process back-to-back.)

What AeroPress User Say

“Whether you’re new to the world of beans or a java Jedi Master, using the Aerobie AeroPress is by far one of the best, if not THE BEST, methods of making a high quality cup of joe.” – UglyMugCoffee.com

“This is only my third morning of using my new AeroPress, but WOW am I impressed. Using the same bean and grind as before (with my Bodum French Press), my coffee tastes SO much better. Gone is the acidity and bitterness. I couldn’t believe how much I enjoyed the my first cup of coffee brewed with this thing.” – Lourroy, customer on Amazon

“I bought a second one of these because I couldn’t stand the coffee at work but didn’t want to be without one for home. I’m a former barista (current coffee snob) and can tell you that this can favorably go up against a $300 machine.” – A. Peters, customer on Amazon

french press

What is a French Press?

The French Press is the old school, tried-and-true method of brewing coffee. Imagine a fancy, refined European coffee house.

Chances are there’s a French Press somewhere in your artificial field of vision.

Though this coffee maker has a particular nation in its name, it may not have been invented by a Frenchman! The first patent for a French Press actually was taken out by a man named Attilio Callimani.

If you’re thinking, “That dude sounds ridiculously Italian,” you’d be correct.

French Press coffee is known for being complex and bold. This is especially obvious when it’s compared with AeroPress coffee.

How Does a French Press Work?

The AeroPress, stovetop coffee makers and vacuum coffee makers brew with pressure. Drip and pour over coffee makers brew with controlled flows of water. All of these methods require some degree of control, either human or mechanical.

The French Press just sits there.

And steeps.

And waits.

You could completely forget your coffee is sitting there (except the fact that you can’t do anything productive until you’ve had your coffee).

The French Press works with basic steeping. Hot water and ground coffee are combined for a period of time, and when you’re satisfied that extraction is complete you press the plunger to force the filter screen (and coffee grounds) downward.

There are two notable impacts from this process:

  1. Lack of a paper filter means no oils are absorbed (lost) during filtering
  2. The mesh isn’t extremely fine, which means your coffee is “murkier”

The resulting coffee is frequently described as “muddy” or “rich” or “full-bodied.” It’s almost like coffee unfiltered (except that, you know, it was filtered).

French Press coffee is a very different experience compared to AeroPress coffee, but both are wonderful in their own ways.

How to use a French Press

Compared to the AeroPress (or any coffee maker for that matter) the French Press is easy.

  1. Heat your water: To whatever temperature you like
  2. Grind your beans: Coarser is better due to the less restrictive filter
  3. Add the coffee: Pour the ground coffee into the French Press
  4. Add some water: Pour in enough water to completely soak the grounds
  5. Wait 45 seconds: This allows the coffee to bloom (no stirring!)
  6. Add remaining water: To get to the appropriate total volume
  7. Wait 4 minutes: No one said this would be quick
  8. Plunge to complete: Add the lid and plunger and slowly press down
  9. Grab a mug (or mugs): Pour and enjoy!

(You don’t need to do steps 4 and 5, but a lot of people like them.)

If you’re more of a visual person, watch this:

French Press Brewing Tips

  1. Try a very coarse grind with a longer extraction time (more than 4 minutes). It could give you a super clean cup…if you’re willing to wait.
  2. Don’t stir after adding the water! This will cause the ground coffee to sink to the bottom and condense, which takes your 4 minute brew time and makes it considerably longer.
  3. Pour all coffee out of the French Press after plunging. This separates the coffee from the grounds and ensures extraction stops, preventing the addition of any unwanted bitter acids.

French Press Pros

Those of the French Press persuasion frequently claim these benefits:

1. Simple to use

Though the step-by-step guide above lists 9 separate steps compared to 10 for the AeroPress Standard Method, that belies the French Press’ ease of use. Grind your coffee, add hot water, wait 4-5 minutes, plunge to strain, enjoy.

You can make almost any brewing method as complicated as you’d like, but the French Press doesn’t need to be.

2. No paper filters

Double benefit here.

First, you don’t need to purchase paper filters or keep them in stock.

Second, and more important for French Press users, no paper filter means no loss of those precious, flavorful oils. If you’re one of the coffee drinkers who grinds their own beans before each brew, this is especially important:

Oils are a great carrier of flavor and so can enhance the taste of food and beverages. But they can also oxidize very easily, leaving a less than desirable note in your coffee. Oxidized oils are more prevalent in dark roasted coffees, older beans (more than 3 weeks after roasting) and pre-ground coffee.

If you grind your own beans, and especially if you use light and medium roasts, the French Press will give you the most complete picture of your coffee’s true taste.

3. Easily makes multiple cups

Whereas the AeroPress makes one cup at a time, the French Press handles multiple. The exact volume depends on the model, but you can easily get 3-4 cups out of most French Press brewers.

4. Makes uniquely flavorful coffee

Tied to Pro #2 above, the French Press makes coffee like no other brew method. It’s complex, unrefined and utterly distinct. While not everyone will love French Press coffee, I’d suggest everyone at least try it!

French Press Cons

No brew method is perfect. These are some of the French Press’ cons:

1. Muddier, “sludgy” coffee

Wait, so I extol the French Press for making uniquely flavored coffee but penalize it for it’s sometimes murky consistency?

This is all personal preference, but most times we talk about coffee we’re talking about a smooth cup of Joe. The French Press just won’t be as smooth.

2. Tougher to clean

Because there’s no paper filter to discard, French Press users are required to do more cleaning.

3. Requires coarser grind

Maybe you prefer a coarse grind, maybe you don’t. With the AeroPress you have much more flexibility, but with the French Press it’s coarse grind or bust. Anything noticeably finer won’t strain as well and could end up resembling cowboy coffee more than you’d like.

4. Takes longer to brew

Generally, shorter is better than longer. The French Press takes longer than almost all other methods. This is due primarily to the necessity of using a coarse grind, which takes longer for complete extraction.

What French Press Users Say

“Using a French press means that everything except the ground coffee is in the cup. You taste all the flavors, which adds to the experience.” – LifeHack.org

“A French press is often treated like Jason Segal’s character in Forgetting Sarah Marshall. He’s actually the one you want, but people tend to flock blindly to the flashy, temperamental types like coffee-siphon-somethings or Russell Brands.” – SeriousEats.com

“Yes, you’ll wind up with an oily, full-bodied cup. Yes, there’s going to be a layer of sediment at the bottom of it. But these facets are all part of the charm of the French-pressed pot of coffee.” – Blog.SurLaTable.com

Search